Pete Alonso's Free Agency: Mets' Desire to Retain, Red Sox's Mixed Signals

Pete Alonso's free agency status remains a key storyline, with the New York Mets expressing a strong desire to bring him back. President of baseball operations David Stearns stated, "We love both Pete and Edwin," and "would love to have them both back." Stearns also emphasized that all aspects of a player's contribution, including on-field performance, clubhouse presence, and community impact, are factored into evaluations. Insider Andy Martino suggests Mets leadership "would be happy to welcome Alonso back in 2026" if he's open to an increased role at designated hitter, though a long-term deal for four or five years seems unlikely. Meanwhile, the Boston Red Sox are reportedly sending "mixed signals" regarding a pursuit of Alonso. While some within the Red Sox organization prefer Alonso over Kyle Schwarber, Boston has first baseman Triston Casas, who would likely see reduced playing time if Alonso were signed. The market for first basemen has also seen movement, with Josh Naylor agreeing to a deal with the Mariners, removing one potential fallback option and suitor for Alonso.