Future of Pete Alonso with Mets Remains Uncertain as Free Agency Approaches

The future of slugger Pete Alonso with the New York Mets remains uncertain as the offseason begins, with both the team and player unsure how free agency will unfold. Despite perceptions that Mets president David Stearns doesn't want him, Stearns and owner Steve Cohen were aligned on wanting Alonso in 2025, though they feared the downside of a long-term commitment. Alonso re-signed on a two-year deal with an opt-out after year one, delivering an outstanding offensive season in 2025 but a subpar defensive campaign. While Stearns and Cohen would reportedly welcome Alonso back in 2026, potentially with an increased role as designated hitter, an increased willingness to offer a four or five-year deal is unlikely given he is now 12 months older. It is currently impossible to predict if other teams like Boston or Tampa Bay will offer a long-term contract, making any definitive statements about his departure premature.