Mets Weigh Pros and Cons of Trading for Former Cy Young Winner Sandy Alcantara

The New York Mets are evaluating a trade for Miami Marlins right-hander Sandy Alcantara, aiming to acquire a frontline starter. Alcantara, the 2022 NL Cy Young winner, returned in 2025 after October 2023 Tommy John surgery. He significantly improved in the second half, posting a 3.33 ERA from July 18, with his control, command, and 97.8 mph fastball velocity returning to 2022 levels. Contractually, he's appealing, under team control through 2027 ($17M in 2026, $21M option in 2027). However, his inconsistency, including a 7.22 ERA in early 2025 and a decline in chase percentage, raises concerns. The Marlins' asking price is expected to be "massive," potentially requiring multiple top prospects. Given the risk versus the high prospect cost, the Mets are leaning against a blockbuster trade for Alcantara, prioritizing other options like Tarik Skubal.